JUSTICE INFO: When Rodrigo Duterte became president of the Philippines in 2016, did people ever imagine the International Criminal Court (ICC) having to deal with the Philippines?
RAUL PANGALANGAN: When I became an ICC judge in 2015, the editor-in-chief of the Philippine Daily Inquirer asked me why I was joining a court that will never have a case from the Philippines. This was a person legendary for her instinct for historical moments, leading a newspaper which had unseated two presidents of the Philippines. Indeed, who could imagine that by 2016, Duterte would be elected president on a campaign promise to kill drug users, and in such a spectacular way? There is a video where the killers are seen riding motorbikes. They stop, redirect the traffic, and shoot down a man in a public market in broad daylight. It was done in the open, no attempt to hide, no attempt at secrecy. It was brazen murder.
How widespread was the support for the ‘‘war on drugs’’?
My impression is that during the entire Duterte period, from 2016 to 2022, while people were being killed left and right, the majority of Filipinos was cheering him on. To give you an example, a member of the staff of the parish of cardinal Pablo Virgilio David asked him: “Why are you attacking our president for the ‘war on drugs’? He’s just doing this for the good of the country.” The bitter irony is that this woman’s son was killed by the police during a drugs operation. Yet she complained merely that the police got the wrong person – she wasn’t objecting to the practice of killing.
“Now more people say: 'Duterte was doing all these bad things to solve the drugs problem. But if the problems are still here until today, maybe it’s not working.'”
And how many people may still support it?
Overall, popularity surveys show that many people still support Duterte and his ”war on drugs”, though I can say with confidence that today the number has gone down. Now more people say: “Duterte was doing all these bad things to solve the drugs problem. But if the problems are still here until today, maybe it’s not working.”
How important is the Duterte trial”, that starts on 30 November at the ICC, for the Philippines?
This is the last hope of traditional justice for the ”war on drugs”. The role of the ICC in the Philippine case is that we will have an authoritative record of the killings, presented in a legally careful way, with all the guarantees of fairness for the accused. If the trial ends with a guilty finding, it’s not just justice for the victims, it’s also educational for reforming our judicial system. Duterte kept on saying to the police: “Just kill them, because if you wait for the courts, nothing will happen”. The ICC will prove that it is possible to respect the rights of the accused and still punish the guilty.
“The Truth Commission is a completely different pathway to justice than the ICC. It’s parallel, but separate and independent.”
This year the Philippine Truth Commission that you chair started its work. Who came up with the idea?
It was cardinal David, the bishop of Caloocan, the city where the biggest number of deaths were reported during the “war on drugs”. There were more deaths elsewhere, but in Caloocan more killings were documented because of cardinal David’s support for the victims’ families. He gave them sanctuary in his church, and they found the courage to speak up.
The Truth Commission is not part of the government. It is a civil society-led institution established to uncover and preserve the truth, give a voice and platform for victims and survivors, and foster societal healing to prevent this national nightmare from happening again. The Truth Commission is a completely different pathway to justice than the ICC. It’s parallel, but separate and independent.
Why is this commission not a government institution?
Initially the cardinal asked the government to form a truth commission. But the authorities were hesitant. Personally I actually prefer that the commission remains private and outside of government. As a former ICC judge, I am painfully aware of the principle of complementarity, which says that the ICC is a court of last resort and will not have jurisdiction to try a case if the accused is already being investigated or prosecuted by national authorities. We should not enable Duterte to claim that the ICC should dismiss his case because the local authorities are already prosecuting him. We should avoid any such risk, lest the former president return home as a victorious hero, “fully vindicated” by the ICC.

Who can come before the Truth Commission?
We have made an open call to any witness who wishes to speak on the extrajudicial killings in the ‘war on drugs’. If people want to speak, they can contact us and bear witness. So far, mothers of young people who were killed have testified before us. Having heard them share their stories and express their grief, I realize that until the Truth Commission hearings, they have had very few moments to tell their stories, to speak of the killed victims as people, as human beings, and that the Commission’s hearings are their way to honor their fallen children or family members.
Is there a risk for those who testify?
The victims show great courage. The mothers really want to speak, and say: “My son has been killed already. This is the least I can do.” We’re quite careful, because they might be harassed for coming forward and be exposed to danger. We take every effort to keep them safe during the period they tell their testimony. But what we discovered after the hearings is that they actually suffer from online harassment of all sorts.
“Another mother asked for our help because her neighbor was angry, saying: 'We have been through enough trouble. Just forget it and move on.' So there’s this kind of pressure from the society, from their own communities.”
Clarita Alia, whose four teenage sons were killed in the city of Davao, told the commission that they were good boys who happened to be addicts. Which reactions did she have to deal with?
There were terrible online comments, saying: “You were a bad mother, stop blaming everyone, you created the problem yourself.” Another mother asked for our help because her neighbor was angry, saying: “We have been through enough trouble. Just forget it and move on.” So there’s this kind of pressure from the society, from their own communities.
Several human rights groups want the Truth Commission to give victims the possibility to testify in a protected manner, as it is done at the ICC. Is that possible?
The ICC of course has more mechanisms for what they call “protective measures” for victims and witnesses. The ICC can also broadcast a testimony by pixelating the image of the witness and applying voice distortion. We don’t have such equipment. If victims wish to testify before the Truth Commission in camera, behind closed doors, we accommodate them.
The killers during the ‘war on drugs’ are police and vigilante groups. Has any perpetrator testified?
I have been informed that some perpetrators are considering to come forward before the Truth Commission. But there is nothing formal yet. Perhaps they are scared and worried for their safety. I am informed as well that some are officers who didn’t want to be part of this ‘war on drugs’ and went on an early retirement. But again, we need to wait for them to actually step forward.
“The Truth Commission has received case files where a victim bore several bullet wounds but the official death certificate says he died of pneumonia.”
What has the Truth Commission discovered regarding the police registering the killings?
The systemic problem is that the official documentation of the crimes is bad. The Truth Commission has received case files where a victim bore several bullet wounds but the official death certificate says he died of pneumonia. Police reports contain seemingly the same language as if they were copied from a template to describe similar killings. They used the same documents all the time and just changed some aspects such as names and places. As a result, the official police reports and autopsies are not reliable. One of our recommendations is improving the forensic capability of our police and, of course, the accuracy of the death certificate and the police report.
The goals of the Commission stretch far: truth telling, accountability, evidence, patterns, healing, institutional reform, historic memory and human rights education.
As you were reciting all this, I thought I better scale this down. So first and foremost, it is giving a voice to the victims as part of the justice process. The victims speaking and being heard is the first goal. Second is establishing the historical record. The Filipino people need to have an authoritative record of what happened during that national nightmare. We want to gather as much information, create an archive and make it accessible to the public. And third, we need to educate the Filipino public. We must reach out especially to the youth and heal our divided society. In short: tell the story, get the facts and educate.
“Perhaps the raw pictures, not curated, is what might convince today’s youth that this all took place. We have to find a way to bring it to them.”
How will you make your findings public?
First, we have to come out with a traditional and proper report, to be published like a book with a table of contents, an introduction and annexes. I worry that most people won’t read it. But it’s the barest minimum of communicating our findings. Beyond that, our findings will have to come to life online. We have podcasts and accessible, online articles. Our archive will feature the work of the photojournalists who were taking real-time photographs during the “war on drugs”. Perhaps the raw pictures, not curated, is what might convince today’s youth that this all took place. But we have to find a way to bring it to them.
How controversial is the Truth Commission in the Philippine society?
Mercifully not too controversial so far. I was worried in the beginning that the usual trolls would say: “This is a biased group”. But so far, the attacks have not been so bad, just the usual snide online comments from anonymous sources, which is par for the course in the Philippines. But we’ll have to wait until we’re coming out with a preliminary report and see the response.
Should this commission be considered an “institution”?
The danger with calling it an institution is that people might think it is designed to be there for a long time. I would like to finish the bulk of the work rather sooner than later especially because Philippine politics is so volatile. We have presidential elections by 2028. That’s less than 2 years from now. We don’t know what will happen then. We better have the truth before the election season, because then we will become political football for the candidates.
“The real challenge of the Truth Commission is reminding people that if you barter your freedom for bread, in the end, you have no freedom and no bread.”
When would you say the Truth Commission has succeeded?
For me, the real test will be making sure it doesn’t happen again. And how do we achieve that? It is by telling people what really happened, and teaching them that there are lines that cannot be crossed. Morally, there are principles we cannot compromise with. But that is a deeper mission.
This was not the first time that we hear the trade-off argument. In the past, during the dictatorship [of Ferdinand Marcos between 1965 and 1986], we were told: “Sacrifice your civil rights in favor of your economic rights; freedom of speech is a first world luxury; because in the Philippines, the basic problem is hunger.” The real challenge of the Truth Commission is reminding people that if you barter your freedom for bread, in the end, you have no freedom and no bread.
How different is it to be an ICC judge from being the chair of a truth commission?
The ICC is a court, with formal and proper procedure. For an ICC judge, the issues are quite clear: it is simply about the guilt or innocence of the accused. The procedure is described in the Rome Statute and is predictable. It’s more difficult to chair the Truth Commission in that we have to maintain, at the same time, the strict legal standards for ascertaining the truth while attending to the non-legal and emotional needs of the victim’s family. We are also keenly aware that we need to establish the truth for the sake of history.
“ICC judges sit in cases completely disconnected from their own political milieu. It is more difficult to be a judge in a case involving one’s own country.”
Did you have to learn how to deal with that?
I had to get accustomed to this. As a lawyer and former judge, I preferred the formality and the structure of the courtroom. But too many formalities will impede the truth-telling by the victims. We want the bereaved mothers to tell their story. So we avoid interrupting them with all the usual evidentiary concerns of lawyers. The first time they told me that during the hearing there will be a photo of the deceased with flowers, followed by the lighting of candles, I was actually hesitant. As a lawyer, I was more used to the boring routines in court. Also, typically ICC judges sit in cases completely disconnected from their own political milieu. It is more difficult to be a judge in a case involving one’s own country.

Raul Cano Pangalangan is a Filipino academic, law professor and former judge at the International Criminal Court (ICC). He was a Philippine delegate in the drafting of the Rome Statute in 1998 and campaigned for its ratification by the Philippines and other Asia-Pacific states. As an ICC judge (2015-2021), he notably presided over the case against Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi.





