ICC: How far does a UN Security Council referral extend?

In the Njeem case, the International Criminal Court has confirmed its jurisdiction over the situation in Libya. However, the judges were divided on the basis for jurisdiction. This is a sensitive debate that also concerns Sudan.

3 judges of the International Criminal Court (ICC)
Judges Reine Alapini-Gansou, Iulia Antoanella Motoc, and María del Socorro Flores Liera of the International Criminal Court. Photo: © ICC-CPI

In a decision of November 2, 2026, a Pre-Trial Chamber of the International Criminal Court (ICC) unanimously confirmed its jurisdiction in the case concerning Osama Elmasry Njeem, also known as Osama Almasri Njeem. This unanimity, however, masks a significant divergence of opinion amongst the judges. For Judges Iulia Antoanella Motoc and Reine Alapini-Gansou, the crimes with which Njeem is charged fall within the Court’s jurisdiction because they remain covered by the United Nations Security Council’s 2011 referral of the situation in Libya. Judge María del Socorro Flores Liera, on the other hand, deemed that the Court’s jurisdiction is based on a declaration submitted by Libya in 2025.

This divergence fuels a sensitive debate, which also concerns Sudan: how long can a Security Council referral remain in force?

On February 26, 2011, whilst Muammar Gaddafi’s regime was violently suppressing a popular uprising in Libya, the Security Council adopted Resolution 1970. Acting under Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter, it decided to refer to the ICC Prosecutor “the situation in the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya since 15 February 2011”.

This referral had a key distinguishing feature: Libya was not – and still is not – a party to the Rome Statute, the ICC’s founding treaty. The Court’s jurisdiction was therefore not based on ratification of the Statute by the State concerned, but on a provision of the Statute itself allowing the Security Council to refer a situation to the Prosecutor.

In this context, a Pre-Trial Chamber issued an arrest warrant for Njeem on January, 18, 2025. He is suspected of having run detention centres in Tripoli in which thousands of people have allegedly been detained for long periods. The warrant relates to war crimes and crimes against humanity, including murder, acts of torture, cruel treatment, rape and other sexual violence, as well as acts of imprisonment and persecution committed at Mitiga prison from February, 15, 2015 onwards.

According to the prosecution, these crimes were committed personally by Njeem, on his orders or with his assistance, and by members of the Special Deterrence Force, also known as SDF/RADA. The victims were reportedly detained on religious grounds, due to their alleged opposition to the ideology of SDF/RADA or their alleged links with other armed groups.

Arrested in Turin, Italy, on January 19, 2025, Njeem was released and returned to Libya two days later by the Italian authorities, under highly controversial circumstances. This led the ICC to find that Italy had breached its obligations to cooperate, and to refer the matter to the Assembly of States Parties, which is due to consider this issue at its next session from November 30 to December 7, 2026, in The Hague.

The defence contested both the ICC’s jurisdiction and the admissibility of the case. In its view, Resolution 1970 relates to a specific crisis: the violence committed in 2011 by the state apparatus of the Gaddafi regime. The acts of which Njeem is accused, committed several years later in a different political and institutional context, do not, it argued, have a sufficient link to that initial situation.

The Chamber unanimously rejected this plea on lack of jurisdiction. However, its three judges did not reach this conclusion by the same reasoning.

A specific crisis or an ongoing crisis?

For Judges Motoc and Alapini-Gansou, Resolution 1970 remains applicable. They stressed the binding nature of decisions adopted by the Security Council and the obligation of UN member states, including Libya, to comply with them.

This binding nature does not, however, resolve the real difficulty: the defence did not contest the validity of Resolution 1970, but rather its scope of application. It had to be determined whether the acts of which Njeem is accused, committed from 2015 onwards, remain sufficiently linked to the crisis that led to the 2011 referral to the Court.

According to ICC case law, a situation may encompass not only crimes already committed or ongoing at the time of referral, but also subsequent crimes, provided they are sufficiently linked to the crisis referred to the Court.

The majority of judges held that this condition was met: the fall of the Gaddafi regime did not bring the Libyan crisis to an end; clashes, institutional fragmentation, activities of armed groups, and external interference have prolonged and transformed the crisis that began in 2011. SDF/RADA is itself said to be a product of this trajectory. Having started out as a revolutionary group fighting Gaddafi’s forces in a district of Tripoli, it is said to have been gradually integrated into structures supported by the Government of National Accord. In 2017, Mitiga Prison was recognised as an official correctional facility and, in 2018, the Special Force was placed under the authority of the Interior Ministry and renamed the “Deterrence Unit for the Fight against Organised Crime and Terrorism”. Some individuals were reportedly detained at Mitiga on grounds of their alleged affiliation with groups involved in the post-2011 tensions.

The judges also draw on UN bodies’ ongoing monitoring of the Libyan crisis. In 2018, the United Nations Secretary-General reported that the UN Mission in Libya had been denied access to Mitiga prison, where some 2,600 people were reportedly being held, mostly without charge or trial. He also highlighted the institutional transformation of SDF/RADA. In 2022, the Panel of Experts on Libya documented arbitrary detentions, acts of torture, cruel treatment and the use of forced labour at Mitiga, identifying Njeem as one of those responsible for supervising detainees. Finally, the Independent Fact-Finding Mission on Libya concluded in 2023 that there were reasonable grounds to believe crimes against humanity had been committed in several places of detention -- notably in the Mitiga complex controlled by SDF/RADA, where it noted a systematic practice of torture.

This continuity is further evident in the ICC Prosecutor’s half-yearly reports to the Security Council. The 29th report, submitted in 2025, expressly linked the arrest warrant against Njeem for crimes committed at Mitiga between February 2015 and October 2024 to the Resolution 1970 referral. In 2026, the 31st report, to which the judges refer, presented the proceedings against Khaled El Hishri, another alleged SDF/RADA leader in Mitiga, as the first judicial proceedings arising from that referral. The Security Council’s repeated acceptance of these reports, without challenging their scope, constitutes, for the majority of the judges, further evidence of the ICC’s continuing jurisdiction. The majority points out, however, that this jurisdiction is neither general nor unlimited: each case must have a sufficient connection to the situation referred in 2011. Yet it must be acknowledged that the more the Libyan crisis is viewed as a continuum since 2011, the more difficult it becomes to identify the limits of this referral.

FIND THIS ARTICLE INTERESTING?
Sign up now for our (free) newsletter to make sure you don't miss out on other publications of this type.

The dissenting judge, Flores Liera, does not question either the validity of Resolution 1970 or the Security Council’s power to refer cases to the ICC. Her dissent centres on the scope of the situation referred to the Court. In her view, the resolution responded to a specific context: the Gaddafi regime’s repression against the civilian population. However, the crimes attributed to Njeem occurred some years later and differ in nature and context. The fact that the Libyan crisis remains on the Security Council’s agenda is therefore not enough in her eyes to extend the Court’s jurisdiction to all crimes subsequently committed on Libyan territory. Precise delimitation is all the more important since Libya is not a party to the Rome Statute. In the absence of a sufficiently direct link to the events of 2011, the mere persistence of unrest in Libya could lead the Court to exercise its jurisdiction indefinitely over a non-party State.

However, this line of reasoning does not in her opinion render the ICC without jurisdiction, because since the arrest warrant was issued Libya has voluntarily accepted the Court’s jurisdiction. On May 12, 2025, Libya did indeed submit a declaration to the ICC, based on a provision of the Rome Statute allowing a non-party State to accept the Court’s jurisdiction. This declaration relates to crimes committed on Libyan territory between 2011 and the end of 2027. It thus covers, in territorial, temporal and material terms, the offences with which Njeem is charged. In Judge Flores Liera’s view, it therefore constitutes an alternative basis for the ICC’s jurisdiction, without it being necessary to extend the scope of Resolution 1970.

The Chamber was thus able to unanimously confirm the ICC’s jurisdiction, despite its members’ disagreement on whether the 2011 referral could cover acts committed several years later. This disagreement could, however, prove decisive in future cases concerning crimes committed after 2027, should Libya fail to renew its acceptance and should the link between those crimes and the crisis that prompted the 2011 referral be contested.

Libyan prosecutions put complementarity to the test

Confirmation of jurisdiction does not mean that the case will necessarily be tried in The Hague. It must still be admissible under the principle of complementarity. Under this principle, a case is not admissible before the ICC if it is the subject of a national investigation or prosecution concerning the same person and substantially the same facts, unless the State concerned lacks the will or capacity to genuinely conduct such proceedings. The defence maintains that proceedings have been initiated in Libya against Njeem. It has produced three documents bearing the signatures and seals of officials from the Libyan Office of the Attorney General. These state that Njeem was questioned in 2025, that proceedings were initiated in relation to acts of torture and cruel or degrading treatment of detainees, and that he was remanded in custody and subsequently brought before a court. The proceedings are said to relate to violations suffered by ten detainees, as well as the death of one detainee as a result of torture.

Although the documents were transmitted directly by the defence and not through official channels, the Chamber states that, in light of the available information, it has no reason to doubt their authenticity. It considers, however, that their content is too general to establish the existence of domestic proceedings concerning the same person or above all for the same conduct covered by the ICC arrest warrant.

It says the documents do not make it possible to precisely identify the authority responsible for proceedings, the case number, the documents examined, the period concerned, the victims, the timetable for proceedings, or the judicial and prison authorities involved. The Chamber also notes that the three documents were drawn up specifically to support Njeem’s defence challenge to the admissibility of the case. However, if the Libyan proceedings are public, it should be possible to produce pre-existing official documents – such as decisions, orders, reports, updates or notifications contained in the national case file.

The burden of proving inadmissibility rests with the party raising the issue. A mere assertion that proceedings are ongoing is not sufficient: it is necessary to provide sufficiently precise and convincing evidence demonstrating that the national authorities are taking steps to establish the person’s responsibility for the same acts as those being examined by the ICC.

The Chamber has ultimately decided to defer its decision on admissibility. These documents appear to reveal a certain degree of judicial activity in Libya which, if properly demonstrated, could be relevant to assessing the admissibility of the case before the ICC in light of the complementarity principle. The Chamber also takes into account the possible difficulties to obtain official documents in the Libyan context. It gave the defence until January 29, 2027 to provide further information, and also invited Libya to submit its observations by the same date.

Unresolved jurisdiction issues

The decision of November 2, 2026 pits two interpretations of the Security Council’s referral against one another. According to the first, a situation referred to the ICC may evolve over time and encompass subsequent crimes provided that a sufficient link to the initial crisis is established. According to the second, the exceptional nature of a referral concerning a non-State Party requires a more restrictive interpretation of its temporal and material limits. The Libyan declaration of 2025 provisionally resolves this conflict by providing an alternative legal basis covering crimes committed up to the end of 2027. However, it does not resolve the debate on principle, which could resurface in Libya or in relation to other situations referred by the Security Council such as Darfur in Sudan, which was referred to the ICC in 2005.

The question of admissibility, meanwhile, remains entirely unresolved. The future of the Njeem case will depend on whether the defence and the Libyan authorities can demonstrate the existence of concrete national proceedings that are sufficiently specific and relate to the same conduct.

Catherine MaiaCATHERINE MAIA

Catherine Maia is professor of international law at Lusófona University (Portugal), visiting professor at Sciences Po Paris, the Catholic Universities of Lyon and Lille (France) and Swiss UMEF (Switzerland). She is also a judge assessor appointed by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees to the French National Court of Asylum (CNDA). Her main areas of specialisation include issues relating to human rights, international criminal law, international humanitarian law and global peace and security.

Republish
Justice Info is on LinkedIn
LinkedIn is the social media platform where our community is most active. Why not join in the discussion and engage with our posts?