On November 17, the Hague-based Kosovo Specialist Chambers (KSC) handed down a second sentence to former Kosovo President Hashim Thaçi. He was found guilty of attempting to obstruct justice, disclosing confidential information about witnesses and trying to interfere with their testimonies in his war crimes trial, in which he was sentenced to 25 years' imprisonment just two months ago. Now, Thaci received another 17 months' jail time, to be served separately.
In front of an almost full public gallery, with family members of the accused attentively listening and leaning forward, single judge Christopher Gosnell spoke of the gravity of the crimes. “Obstruction of official duties relating to ongoing trial proceedings are an attack on the integrity of the judicial system, which is an essential foundation for the rule of law.”
On September 16, Thaçi and three other high-ranking figures of the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) were convicted of war crimes committed during the 1998-1999 Kosovo war to gain independence from Serbia, in a trial that started in the spring of 2023. Between July and October that year, the judge now found that Thaçi instructed two visitors to the detention centre to pass on instructions to prosecution witnesses Rrustem Mustafa and Bislim Zyrapi, both former KLA top figures, on how to testify, presenting a narrative that favoured him. He was also found to have revealed information about them, including in the case of a protected witness. None of the other co-defendants were found guilty of participating in the disclosure.
An indictment for this case of administration of justice arrived in late 2024, and alongside Thaçi, it included four other co-accused who visited him in detention: former Kosovo Intelligence Agency chief Bashkim Smakaj, former Malisheva mayor Isni Kilaj, former KLA member Fadil Fazliu and former minister of justice Hajredin Kuçi, who was working on the defence team of another man in the war crimes trial. They all shook hands and shared a few words with Thaci as he entered the courtroom for the trial verdict. All four were discharged by the judge. Fazliu and Smakaj received a 12-month sentence but had already served that time; Kuçi received a one-month conditional sentence, and Kilaj was found not guilty. Judge Gosnell said that Kosovo's former president and prime minister’s attempted obstruction “targeted prosecutors and judges” involved in the war crimes case. Thaci was also found guilty of leading and organising Fazliu and Smakaj, together with others, who collaborated in trying to influence witnesses.
The prosecution had asked for a six-year sentence for Thaci, to be added to his war crimes one, mentioning in their final brief the “deterrence” value this could have in other cases of obstruction in the Balkan country.
All parties will now have 30 days to say whether they want to appeal, while Thaçi, who pleaded not guilty, is expected to appeal his war crimes sentence by November 27.
Risky visits
The main evidence in the case was the audio recordings of the visits that the accused men paid to Thaçi in detention, and their transcripts, which the judge found “an accurate record of what was said during those visits,” dismissing the defence’s challenges to their credibility.
On July 2 2023, Fazliu visited Thaci in prison and received messages to convey to Rrustem Mustafa, who was scheduled to testify. “Tell him, ‘Be brief, be brief. Be Brief. Be brief,’” and “Tell him, ‘They have a lot of trust in you and they can’t wait for you to come because you are decisive and can settle this’,” read the judge from the visit’s transcript. He added that Thaci told Fazliu that Mustafa should say that “the boss was Demaçi,” who in the late 1990s headed the political branch of the KLA before leaving it. “These were not mere reminiscences about the war amongst old friends, but instructions for onward transmission,” the judge said. The day after, through his son, Fazliu scheduled a meeting with Mustapha, and the three met in Pristina, Kosovo’s capital, and he passed on the instructions.
Months later, on October 7, 2023, Smakaj visited Thaçi in detention together with another man, found to be actively participating in the obstruction, and received messages for Bislim Zyrapi. According to the judge, the evidence shows that a written document with instructions on his testimony, found in Thaçi’s laptop and predating the visit, was printed in the detention unit and given to the two visitors. The same document was later seized during Smakaj’s and residence search. The accused was also in contact with Zyrapi in the period after the visit, said the judge. “I am satisfied that Mr Smakaj met Mr Zyrapi on 24 October 2023 and conveyed instructions to him about his upcoming testimony.”
When it came to Kilaj’s visit, the judge said that “the evidence does not establish that the third visitor during the 6 October visit, Mr Kryeziu, participated in the common obstructive action,” one of the requirements of the crime committed by a group, nor that “Kilaj took any steps” after his visit to contact the witness. He acquitted the man.
Kuçi was also found guilty only of one of the counts of contempt of court, for sending a message to Mustafa after a television appearance where he commented on the merits of the war crimes case. “As innocuous as this message might seem, Mr Kuçi was at the time a member of one of the other Case 6 [the war crimes trial] Defence teams and, as such, was prohibited by judicial order from contacting any Prosecution witness,” the judge read from the summary of the judgment.
This verdict “shows that with the proper tools, international tribunals can combat witness intimidation, which is a challenge at many of them,” Alex Whiting told Justice Info. He is a Professor at Harvard Law School, and until 2023, he worked as the Head of Investigations, Deputy Specialist Prosecutor, and Acting Specialist Prosecutor at the KSC. According to him, the fact that the prosecution could have recordings of the visits, phone and computer records, and documents seized in Kosovo is “unusual” for a war crimes tribunal. “The ability to use all those investigative tools, both in the prison, with a court order and then in Kosovo, allowed the prosecution to penetrate the obstruction that was happening because obviously they were doing it quite carefully.” He added this is a “precedent” and that it “shows what is necessary for the prosecution to be able to fight back against obstruction”.
The unchanged critics
Jashar Fazliu, first cousin of the defendant, shared his discontent with the verdict and voiced the malcontent with the court that characterises many Kosovars. “It is a one-sided court,” he told Justice Info. He added that “all the men inside were liberation fighters, not criminals”. He said that the judgments are pronounced in the name of the people of Kosovo, “but we disagree”.
The reason behind the wording of the judgments stem from the very set-up of the court. Created in 2015 by the Kosovo parliament under pressure from the country's western allies to handle ex-KLA fighters, the Chambers are formally part of the Kosovo judicial system but are located in the Netherlands and are fully staffed by internationals. The Chambers were specifically set outside of Kosovo because of worries over witness protection in the Balkan country. Over the court’s existence, three out of its six trials dealt with this issue.
However, following the September verdict for war crimes, protests erupted in Kosovo under the slogan “not in my name”. They lasted for several weeks. The government also took some steps to try and curb the court’s power. On October 6, Kosovo’s parliament voted to amend the law on the Specialist Chambers, but the President returned it to Parliament for a review. The EU and the UK have opposed this change, as the court was established via an international agreement. The government has now criticised this new judgment, saying that “justice must not only be served, but also be fair, transparent and credible,” Kosovo media reported.
“Most of the people in Kosovo do not support the Specialist Chambers in The Hague and consider it biased against ethnic Albanians,” explains BIRN Kosovo correspondent Xhorxhina Bami, who has closely followed the court. “Today's verdict just adds to this perception of the court.” She said that Mustafa and Zyrapi’s testimonies supported the claims of Thaci's defence and are also “very much in par with beliefs of ethnic Albanians in Kosovo and abroad and supporters of the KLA”.
A key issue
In a press release issued after the verdict, the Specialist Prosecutor Kimberly West welcomed the convictions and said that it sends the message that those “who attempt to subvert the rule of law” will be held accountable, “no matter their status or position”. She added that her office “will remain steadfast in investigating and prosecuting offences against the administration of justice”.
“This was really not a side issue for the court, but it was actually the key issue,” Ana Srovin Coralli, Postdoctoral Researcher at the University of St. Gallen and at the Geneva Graduate Institute’s Global Governance Centre, told Justice Info. “Because of the level of intimidation, not only in that it had an impact on the witnesses, but because it was also so visible, I think the court felt the urgency to react.” According to her, it is important that this “is separately acknowledged in a judgment”.
However, Srovin Coralli questions the wider role that criminal courts can play and to what extent this could have an impact in Kosovo. "Playing a meaningful role in the establishment of international criminal justice requires much more than sentencing a few perpetrators. The tribunal charged with this task must also aspire to bring about real, lasting change, for example, by changing the way people think and influencing society. That's what concerns me here, because I don't think the tribunal has necessarily achieved that yet. There is so much room to strengthen its impact, and the sentences handed down should be only a starting point for a much broader contribution to building a truly stable and sustainable peace in society.”






